
Peep Club
Eye Rescue Lidstick™
Researched by the The Top Finds editors · How we pick
The Top Finds is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. We never accept payment for placement, and prices and availability are set by the retailer at the time of click.
Best for
Someone with dry, tired or sensitive eyes who wants a fragrance-free, eyelid-safe balm to add to a nighttime routine.
Skip if
You want a long-lasting jar, a product to wear under mascara, or a treatment for an eye condition that your eye doctor hasn't approved.
Price tier
Mid-range
$35
The verdict
The Eye Rescue Lidstick is an overnight balm in a click-pen format. Peep Club says it was developed with optometrists for dry, tired or sensitive eyes and leaves out preservatives, alcohol and added fragrance. It suits people who want an eyelid-safe nighttime balm, but the short 1–3 month lifespan and the no-lash-line rule are real trade-offs.
What stands out
- Click-pen format dispenses a small amount at a time, which helps keep product off the lash line
- Formulated without preservatives, alcohol or artificial fragrance, per the brand
- Made for use on the upper eyelid as well as under and around the eyes
- Vegan, cruelty free and plant based, with a recyclable box and internal packaging
- Small, travel-friendly size
Worth knowing
- Each stick is meant to last only 1–3 months with daily use, so it needs frequent replacing
- Not designed for use under mascara, which it could smudge, and must stay off the lashes and lash line
- Contact lenses must be removed before applying, and a patch test is advised for particularly sensitive eyes or skin
- Made in an environment that uses nut oils, and the brand rates its own sustainability only 3 out of 5 stars
Our review
What it is
The Eye Rescue Lidstick is a balm for the skin around the eyes, sold in a twist-free "clicky pen" that the brand says dispenses a small, controlled amount per use. Peep Club says the formula took three years to develop with optometrists, which is why it's pitched at both beauty and eye-care concerns rather than just wrinkles or dark circles.
The ingredient list starts with grape seed oil and plant waxes (rice bran and a sumac-derived wax), then adds shea butter, evening primrose oil, borage seed oil, sunflower seed oil, oat kernel oil, manuka oil and kakadu plum extract. The brand describes it as vegan, cruelty free and plant based. It also says the formula is free of preservatives, alcohol and artificial fragrance, and that it uses lightweight, noncomedogenic oils.
Who it's for
Peep Club designed this for dry, tired or sensitive eyes, and says it will be especially useful for people with blepharitis. It lists the skin type as all, including sensitive, and says it's dermatologically tested. Think of it as a nighttime step after cleansing, applied thinly over closed eyes: under the eyes, at the sides and on the upper lid.
It's also built to pair with the brand's Heated Eye Wand LED+, which it says benefits from the balm's slip. You don't need the wand, though. The brand says the Lidstick can be used on its own after cleaning the eye area.
What stands out
The application format is the main differentiator. A pen that dispenses a little at a time makes it easier to keep product off the lash line, which the instructions say to avoid.
The ingredient story is also unusually specific. The brand credits oat ceramides with supporting the skin barrier, evening primrose oil with softening the look of fine lines, kakadu plum with brightening, borage oil with calming, and manuka oil with soothing red, inflamed eyelids. Those are the brand's claims about what each ingredient does, not independent findings. The absence of preservatives, alcohol and added fragrance is a meaningful filter for anyone who reacts to common eye-area products.
It's also described as pocket and travel friendly. The brand says some people use it in the daytime under concealer or over makeup for a dewy look, though it isn't designed for use under mascara and could make mascara smudge.
The trade-offs
It's a small product, and the brand deliberately makes it that way: each stick is meant to last one to three months with daily use, so it isn't discarded past its expiry date. That means regular repurchasing, and the brand's own sustainability rating for this product is three out of five stars for that reason, though the box and internal packaging are recyclable.
The usage rules are strict. Remove contact lenses first, keep the balm off the lashes and away from the lash line, and stop and rinse with cool water if irritation occurs. Even for a formula designed around sensitive eyes, the brand recommends a patch test if your eyes or skin are particularly sensitive. It's also made in an environment that uses nut oils, so anyone with a nut allergy should read the ingredient list and check with a doctor.
Finally, the blepharitis positioning is a brand claim. If you have a diagnosed eye condition, treat this as a skin-care step and ask your eye doctor before relying on it.
How to decide
This makes sense if you want a gentle, fragrance-free nighttime balm for the eyelids and surrounding skin and don't mind a product with a short shelf life. It makes less sense if you want a long-lasting jar, a daytime-under-mascara product, or a treatment for a medical eye condition. If you already use an eye cream, the brand says to let it sink in for about five minutes before applying the Lidstick over it.
Common questions
Eye Rescue Lidstick™, answered
How do you use the Peep Club Eye Rescue Lidstick?
Remove contact lenses and cleanse the eye area. Click the pen two or three times, then apply a thin layer over closed eyes: under the eyes, at the sides and on the upper lid. Keep it off the lashes and lash line. The brand recommends using it every evening.
Can you use the Lidstick during the day?
The brand designed it to work best overnight, but says it can be used in the daytime under concealer or over makeup to refresh it. It isn't designed for use under mascara and could make mascara smudge.
How long does one Eye Rescue Lidstick last?
The brand says each stick lasts about one to three months with daily use, depending on how much you apply. It's made as a mini product so you finish it before the expiry date, which is printed on the outer box.
Is the Eye Rescue Lidstick safe for sensitive eyes?
Peep Club designed it with sensitive eyes in mind and says it contains no known eye irritants. It still recommends a patch test if your eyes or skin are particularly sensitive. If irritation occurs, rinse with cool water and stop using it.
Can you use the Lidstick with an eye cream or serum?
Yes, according to the brand. Apply the cream or serum first, wait about five minutes for it to sink in, then apply the Lidstick over it. Most eye creams are meant only for under and around the eyes, so the Lidstick can cover the eyelid.
What is in the Peep Club Lidstick?
Key ingredients include grape seed oil, rice bran and sumac-derived waxes, shea butter, evening primrose oil, borage seed oil, sunflower seed oil, oat kernel oil, manuka oil and kakadu plum extract. The brand says it has no preservatives, alcohol or artificial fragrance.
Ready to buy
Eye Rescue Lidstick™
The Top Finds is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. We never accept payment for placement, and prices and availability are set by the retailer at the time of click.
More from Beauty & Skincare
Related finds

cuddle+kind
Beatrice's print (blush) (8"x10")
About Beatrice's print This stunning print features a breathtakingly hand painted watercolor rendition of Beatrice exploring a field of flowers with an adorable

cuddle+kind
Beatrice the mouse (blush)
About Beatrice (blush) Birthday: May 5th Hiya! I’m always up to something, whether it’s creating a new gadget or finding a clever way to solve a tricky problem.

Dabble & Dollop
Coconut Body Lotion
Bring tropical comfort to daily routines with our Coconut Body Lotion. This lightweight, quick-absorbing moisturizer hydrates gently while leaving behind a crea
Peep Club
$35