The Top Finds
Pick 3 Jar Candles Gift Set

Brooklyn Candle

Pick 3 Jar Candles Gift Set

Researched by the The Top Finds editors · How we pick

$92$102−10%
Check price at Brooklyn Candle
How buying works: The Top Findsis an independent editorial site and doesn't sell this item. Clicking “Shop” takes you to Brooklyn Candle's own website, where you complete checkout — they handle pricing, inventory, shipping, and returns. Price last checked Nov 18, 2026; current price and stock are set by Brooklyn Candle at click time.

The Top Finds is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. We never accept payment for placement, and prices and availability are set by the retailer at the time of click.

new-arrivalgmc-pilot

Best for

Someone gifting a scent-sensitive, eco-conscious person who wants a considered, curated trio rather than a single safe candle.

Skip if

You or the recipient want a strong, room-filling fragrance throw — soy wax by design burns lighter than paraffin.

Price tier

Mid-range

$92

The verdict

Brooklyn Candle's Pick 3 gift set turns a common gifting problem — choosing one scent for someone with taste — into the whole point: you pick three, they get a curated trio in packaging that looks like it came from a boutique, not a big-box candle aisle.

What stands out

  • Fully customizable — choose any three scents from the brand's full lineup
  • Arrives in gift-ready luxury packaging with no additional wrapping needed
  • 100% soy wax formula designed for fragrance-sensitive and allergy-prone noses
  • Vegan, cruelty-free, phthalate-free, and petroleum-free — clean ingredient profile
  • Brand-provided trio suggestions make fragrance selection much easier

Worth knowing

  • Soy wax throws noticeably less scent than paraffin — the brand acknowledges this directly
  • Premium price for three candles; buyers primarily paying for clean ingredients and presentation
  • Scent selection is only as good as your knowledge of the recipient's taste — the wide menu can be overwhelming

Our review

What It Is

Brooklyn Candle Studio lets you hand-select any three jar candles from their full fragrance library, which then arrive packaged together in a luxury box and sleeve designed to be given as-is — no wrapping required. The set ships from Brooklyn, where the candles are made in small batches with 100% soy wax, lead-free cotton wicks, and fragrance oils blended with essential oils. Every candle in the lineup is vegan, cruelty-free, phthalate-free, and petroleum-free.

Who It's For

This is a gifting product at heart, and it solves a specific problem: you know someone well enough to know what kind of atmosphere they want in their home, but not which single fragrance to commit to. The build-your-own structure lets you match a mood — woodsy and grounding, fresh and floral, meditative, or warm and spiced — rather than gambling on one jar. It also works for self-purchase if you're the kind of person who burns different candles depending on the room or the season and wants to stock up thoughtfully.

What Stands Out

The brand's suggested trio combinations — Fern + Moss / Catskills / Kyoto Woods for a woodsy-green mood; Bali / Palo Santo / Santorini for something more meditative — function as useful editorial guidance for shoppers who are overwhelmed by a full fragrance menu. That curation support is genuinely useful when you're buying for someone else.

The soy wax formula is worth taking seriously as a differentiator. Brooklyn Candle is explicit that they use pure soy because paraffin releases benzene and formaldehyde when burned, and they specifically design for fragrance-sensitive noses, allergy sufferers, and people prone to fragrance-induced migraines. If you or the recipient falls into that category, this distinction matters more than it might seem on a product page.

The packaging is purpose-built for gifting — the luxury box and sleeve mean you're buying a ready-to-give object, not a trio of candles you'll need to bundle yourself.

The Trade-Offs

Brooklyn Candle is admirably upfront about the most important one: soy wax candles throw less scent than paraffin. If the recipient expects a candle to fill a large open-plan space with fragrance, this will disappoint. The brand positions their candles as something that complements a room rather than dominates it — a meaningful distinction for anyone who finds heavily scented candles headache-inducing, but a real drawback for anyone who measures a candle's quality by how far the scent travels.

At this price point for three candles, you're paying for the clean ingredient story, the Brooklyn provenance, and the gift-ready presentation. Shoppers who just want strong scent throw and don't care about soy vs. paraffin will find better value elsewhere.

How to Decide

The case for buying is clearest when the person you're gifting is either scent-sensitive (or lives with someone who is), environmentally minded, or has a home aesthetic that matches the brand's positioning — considered, not maximalist. The suggested trios give you a real shortcut: pick the mood that fits them, not just a random fragrance. If the recipient has strong opinions about scent strength and burns candles specifically for room-filling fragrance impact, look at a different brand first.

Common questions

Pick 3 Jar Candles Gift Set, answered

How many scents does Brooklyn Candle offer to choose from?

The brand offers a full fragrance library to mix and match from; the exact count can vary by season. Their website lists current available scents when you build the set.

Are Brooklyn Candle candles safe for people with fragrance sensitivities?

The brand designs specifically for fragrance-sensitive noses and says the candles are intended to complement rather than overpower a space. They use phthalate-free, petroleum-free fragrance oils and pure soy wax, which doesn't emit the benzene or formaldehyde associated with paraffin wax when burned.

Why do soy candles smell weaker than other candles?

Soy wax has a lower melting point and doesn't hold or release fragrance as aggressively as paraffin. Brooklyn Candle is transparent about this trade-off — their candles are designed for a lighter, cleaner scent experience rather than maximum throw.

Can I choose any combination of three scents, or are there set options?

The set is fully customizable — you hand-select the three fragrances. The brand also offers suggested trio combinations organized by mood (woodsy, floral, meditative, spicy) if you need a starting point.

Where are Brooklyn Candle candles made?

Made in Brooklyn, New York, according to the brand.

Is this a good gift for someone who doesn't like strong candles?

It's a particularly good fit. The soy wax formula and the brand's stated design philosophy — candles that complement rather than overpower — make this a stronger choice for scent-sensitive or light-preference recipients than most mass-market candle sets.

Ready to buy

Pick 3 Jar Candles Gift Set

Check price at Brooklyn Candle

The Top Finds is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. We never accept payment for placement, and prices and availability are set by the retailer at the time of click.

Brooklyn Candle

$92$102

Check price at Brooklyn Candle