
Brooklyn Candle
Holiday Candle Votive Quartet
Researched by the The Top Finds editors · How we pick
The Top Finds is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. We never accept payment for placement, and prices and availability are set by the retailer at the time of click.
Best for
Someone who wants to rotate through multiple holiday scent moods — or needs a polished, ingredient-conscious gift that goes beyond a generic store candle.
Skip if
You prefer a single large candle for extended daily burn or want the flexibility to return if the scents don't land.
Price tier
Mid-range
$37.5
The verdict
Brooklyn Candle's Holiday Votive Quartet offers four rigorously composed seasonal scents — from a smoky Fireplace to a spice-laden Pomander — in a clean-burning soy format that makes it one of the more thoughtful holiday candle sets at this price.
What stands out
- Four distinct, well-constructed scent profiles covering the major holiday moods
- 100% soy wax, phthalate-free, petroleum-free, vegan, and cruelty-free
- Made in Brooklyn with lead-free cotton wicks and essential-oil-infused fragrance
- Limited-edition format makes it a natural seasonal gift
- Colorful, maximalist aesthetic stands out on a holiday table
Worth knowing
- Votive format means shorter burn life than a standard-size candle
- Final sale — no refunds or exchanges, which is a real risk for a scent you can't smell first
- Limited edition means it may sell out and not restock
- Four scents means you may love two and merely like the others
Our review
What It Is
Brooklyn Candle's Holiday Candle Votive Quartet bundles four limited-edition seasonal scents into one set: Cypress Tree, Fireplace, Pomander, and Wild Fig. Each votive is made in Brooklyn with 100% soy wax, lead-free cotton wicks, and fragrance oils blended with essential oils. The brand describes the aesthetic inspiration as a Studio 54 holiday party — maximalist, colorful, unapologetically festive.
The Four Scents
The lineup covers the major holiday fragrance moods without doubling up. Cypress Tree is the classic fresh-cut tree scent, built on cypress, pine, juniper, and fir balsam with a cedar-sandalwood dry-down. Fireplace opens on resinous spruce and pine, then settles into charred cedar and sandalwood with frankincense and myrrh at the base — a more complex take on the "cozy fire" genre. Pomander is the spiced citrus entry: orange peel and bergamot on top, nutmeg, clove, and cardamom in the heart, smoky incense and sandalwood underneath. Wild Fig is the outlier — lush and slightly glamorous, fig leaf and jasmine over moss and musk, the brand's version of a sophisticated holiday cocktail hour rather than a snowy cabin.
Who It's For
Buyers who want to rotate scents through the holiday season rather than commit to a single candle will find this format genuinely practical. It also works as a ready-to-give gift: the four distinct scents mean the recipient is likely to connect with at least two or three of them. Shoppers who care about ingredient transparency — soy wax, phthalate-free, petroleum-free, vegan, cruelty-free — will find Brooklyn Candle checks those boxes more rigorously than most mass-market holiday sets.
What Stands Out
The scent profiles are more layered than the typical "pine and vanilla" holiday candle. Each one has a discernible top-heart-base structure, which the brand details explicitly — a signal that fragrance development here is taken seriously. The made-in-Brooklyn positioning and clean-formula commitments are consistent with Brooklyn Candle's broader brand, not just seasonal marketing language. The colorful votive format photographs well, which matters if this is going under a tree or on a holiday table.
The Trade-Offs
Votives burn faster than standard 8 oz candles, so buyers expecting weeks of daily use from each one should adjust expectations. The set is final sale with no refunds or exchanges — that's a meaningful consideration for a scent purchase where you can't smell before buying. As a limited edition, availability isn't guaranteed past the holiday window, which cuts both ways: it creates urgency, but means no restocking if you fall hard for one scent.
How to Decide
If you want a single-scent candle for everyday use, a full-size option makes more sense. But if the appeal is variety — different moods for different moments across November and December — or you need a polished gift that signals genuine effort, this quartet earns its place.
Common questions
Holiday Candle Votive Quartet, answered
What wax does Brooklyn Candle use?
Brooklyn Candle uses 100% soy wax across its candles, including this votive set. Soy wax burns cleaner and longer than paraffin and is a renewable resource.
Are Brooklyn Candle votives vegan and cruelty-free?
Yes. The brand states this set is vegan, cruelty-free, phthalate-free, and petroleum-free, with lead-free cotton wicks.
What do the four holiday scents smell like?
Cypress Tree is a fresh pine-and-juniper tree farm scent. Fireplace is smoky and resinous with frankincense and myrrh. Pomander is spiced citrus — orange, clove, and cardamom. Wild Fig is earthy-sweet with fig, jasmine, moss, and musk.
Can I return Brooklyn Candle votives if I don't like the scent?
No — this set is listed as final sale with no refunds or exchanges, so it's worth researching the scent profiles before purchasing.
Are the Holiday Votive Quartets available year-round?
The brand designates this as a Limited Edition product, which typically means it's seasonal and may not be restocked once sold out.
Where are Brooklyn Candle candles made?
Brooklyn Candle candles are made in Brooklyn, New York.
Ready to buy
Holiday Candle Votive Quartet
The Top Finds is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. We never accept payment for placement, and prices and availability are set by the retailer at the time of click.
More from Home & Garden
Related finds

Porte + Hall
The Innerweave - Chevron (Dark Grey) / 5 x 7 Area Mat
Our mats look like they're made from natural fibers, but they perform so much better. What we love about them: they are shed-resistant, slip-resistant and easy

Porte + Hall
The Innerweave - Chevron (Dark Grey) / Runner
Our mats look like they're made from natural fibers, but they perform so much better. What we love about them: they are shed-resistant, slip-resistant and easy

Porte + Hall
The Innerweave - Chevron (Dark Grey) / Doormat
Our mats look like they're made from natural fibers, but they perform so much better. What we love about them: they are shed-resistant, slip-resistant and easy
Brooklyn Candle
$37.5$75